Scarlatti — Selected Sonatas, Volume 3

Catalog: CACD 9210-2 • Status: Identified

CD Covers

Hatto cover
Concert Artist 9210-2 • Joyce Hatto
Benoit cover
Pavane ADW 7326 • Prisca Benoit
Tipo cover
EMI 49078 • Maria Tipo
Babayan cover
Pro Piano 224 506 • Sergei Babayan
Okashiro cover
Pro Piano 224 501 • Chitose Okashiro
Szokolay cover
Naxos 8.550252 • Balázs Szokolay

Capsule Summary

This CD draws on five different sources, with most tracks taken from Prisca Benoit’s Pavane recording. Eight of the tracks were subjected to tempo manipulation — in some cases exceeding 10%.

Thanks to Seth Adelman for identifying all sources; his original post can be read here.

Sources

  • Prisca Benoit — Pavane ADW 7326 (Tracks 1–2, 7–9, 15, 17–19)
  • Maria Tipo — EMI 49078 (Tracks 3, 5, 6, 12, 16)
  • Sergei Babayan — Pro Piano 224 506 (Tracks 4, 13, 14, 20)
  • Chitose Okashiro — Pro Piano 224 501 (Track 10)
  • Balázs Szokolay — Naxos 8.550252 (Track 11)

Track Evidence

Track 1 — Sonata in G major L 388 / K 2

Benoit waveform

Benoit (1:36)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (1:46) — slowed ≈ 10.8%

Track 2 — Sonata in B minor L 449 / K 27

Benoit waveform

Benoit (3:52)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (3:52)

Track 3 — Sonata in D minor L 423 / K 32

Tipo waveform

Tipo (2:26)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (2:26)

Track 4 — Sonata in A minor L 241 / K 54

Babayan waveform

Babayan (3:50)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (4:04) — slowed ≈ 6.1%

Track 5 — Sonata in G major L 80 / K 79

Tipo waveform

Tipo (2:15)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (2:15)

Track 6 — Sonata in A minor L 138 / K 109

Tipo waveform

Tipo (4:58)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (4:42) — sped ≈ 5.5%

Track 7 — Sonata in G major L 487 / K 125

Benoit waveform

Benoit (2:14)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (2:30) — slowed ≈ 11.5%

Track 8 — Sonata in E major L 21 / K 162

Benoit waveform

Benoit (4:53)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (5:04) — slowed ≈ 3.7%

Track 9 — Sonata in E-flat major L 142 / K 193

Benoit waveform

Benoit (4:05)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (4:05)

Track 10 — Sonata in C major L S2 / K 420

Okashiro waveform

Okashiro (2:46)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (2:46)

Track 11 — Sonata in C-sharp minor L 256 / K 247

Szokolay waveform

Szokolay (4:23)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (4:23)

Track 12 — Sonata in A major L 191 / K 342

Tipo waveform

Tipo (2:03)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (2:03)

Track 13 — Sonata in F minor L 480 / K 365

Babayan waveform

Babayan (3:51)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (3:51)

Track 14 — Sonata in F major L 385 / K 445

Babayan waveform

Babayan (2:37)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (2:55) — slowed ≈ 11.5%

Track 15 — Sonata in D major L S11 / K 415

Benoit waveform

Benoit (1:36)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (1:36)

Track 16 — Sonata in G major L 333 / K 425

Tipo waveform

Tipo (2:44)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (2:44)

Track 17 — Sonata in B-flat major L S39 / K 441

Benoit waveform

Benoit (2:56)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (2:56)

Track 18 — Sonata in G minor L 340 / K 476

Benoit waveform

Benoit (3:41)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (3:52) — slowed ≈ 4.9%

Track 19 — Sonata in E major L 430 / K 531

Benoit waveform

Benoit (3:24)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (3:24)

Track 20 — Sonata in G major L S28 / K 547

Babayan waveform

Babayan (3:36)

Hatto waveform

Hatto (3:51) — slowed ≈ 7.1%