Mendelssohn

Piano Concerto No. 1
Piano Concerto No. 2
Capriccio brillant
Rondo capriccioso

Catalog: CACD 9070-2 • Status: Identified

CD Covers

Hatto cover
Concert Artist 9070-2 • Joyce Hatto
Brautigam cover
BIS 718 • Ronald Brautigam
Edelmann cover
RCA 7988 • Sergei Edelmann
Hobson cover
Arabesque 6639 • Ian Hobson

Capsule Summary

This disc contains performances from by three different pianists. Both concertos derive from Ronald Brautigam’s BIS recording. The Capriccio brillant is from Sergei Edelmann’s RCA release, and the Rondo capriccioso is by Ian Hobson on Arabesque. Every track has been slowed down to varying degrees, with the Andante and Rondo sections of the Rondo capriccioso altered by different amounts.

All tracks identified.

Sources

  • Ronald Brautigam — BIS 718 (Piano Concertos Nos. 1 & 2)
  • Sergei Edelmann — RCA 7988 (Capriccio brillant Op. 22)
  • Ian Hobson — Arabesque 6639 (Rondo capriccioso Op. 14)

Track Evidence

Track 1 — Piano Concerto No. 1 in G minor Op. 25 – I Molto allegro con fuoco

Brautigam waveform

Ronald Brautigam (6:58)

Hatto waveform

Joyce Hatto (7:28) — Slowed down by 30 seconds

Track 2 — Piano Concerto No. 1 in G minor Op. 25 – II Andante

Brautigam waveform

Ronald Brautigam (5:51)

Hatto waveform

Joyce Hatto (6:06) — Slowed down by 15 seconds

Track 3 — Piano Concerto No. 1 in G minor Op. 25 – III Presto – Molto allegro e vivace

Brautigam waveform

Ronald Brautigam (5:45)

Hatto waveform

Joyce Hatto (6:00) — Slowed down by 15 seconds

Track 4 — Piano Concerto No. 2 in D minor Op. 40 – I Allegro appassionato

Brautigam waveform

Ronald Brautigam (8:09)

Hatto waveform

Joyce Hatto (8:22) — Slowed down by 13 seconds

Track 5 — Piano Concerto No. 2 in D minor Op. 40 – II Adagio molto sostenuto

Brautigam waveform

Ronald Brautigam (6:22)

Hatto waveform

Joyce Hatto (6:52) — Slowed down by 30 seconds

Track 6 — Piano Concerto No. 2 in D minor Op. 40 – III Allegro vivace

Brautigam waveform

Ronald Brautigam (5:55)

Hatto waveform

Joyce Hatto (6:10) — Slowed down by 15 seconds

Track 7 — Capriccio brillant Op. 22 – Andante

Edelmann waveform

Sergei Edelmann (2:38)

Hatto waveform

Joyce Hatto (2:48) — Slowed down by 10 seconds

Track 8 — Capriccio brillant Op. 22 – Allegro

Edelmann waveform

Sergei Edelmann (9:19)

Hatto waveform

Joyce Hatto (9:29) — Slowed down by 10 seconds

Track 9 — Andante and Rondo Capriccioso Op. 14

Hobson waveform

Ian Hobson (5:59)

Hatto waveform

Joyce Hatto (6:01) — Andante slowed down by 11 seconds; Rondo slowed down by 5 seconds